At midnight last night, millions of gamers finally got their hands on the long-awaited Grand Theft Auto 6. And it seems that plenty have decided that today is not a day for work.
The release has reportedly prompted a surge in holiday requests. According to HR software provider Breathe HR, annual leave bookings for 19 November are 18% higher than on comparable Thursdays in previous years. It estimates that an additional 240,000 UK employees will be taking the day off. And those are just the employees who have booked holiday.
But what about those employees who haven’t booked time off? Will employers find themselves dealing with an outbreak of ‘GTA flu’? Aldi Scotland pre-empted it with a tongue-in-cheek social media post yesterday reminding workers that “tomorrow’s sickie needs groundwork today. After lunch: “Is it just me or is it roasting in here?” 3pm: A massive fake sniff. Maybe a wee cough for good measure. 5pm: “Dinnae think I’ll be making it in tomorrow, troops.” Soup, tissues and a bottle of Irn-Bru. All the essentials. See you Monday, ya bunch of skivers.” But, joking aside, it’s a familiar HR problem. Think of the employee who calls in sick immediately after a bank holiday weekend, the football fan who misses work following a big World Cup match, or the employee whose sickness absence coincides precisely with a previously refused holiday request.
How should employers respond when the timing of an absence raises questions?
When the timing raises questions
Employers are entitled to question patterns of absence. But timing alone doesn’t establish dishonesty. An employee who has been refused holiday and then calls in sick may genuinely fall ill on that date.
The importance of looking at the wider picture was illustrated in Atif v Dolce & Gabbana UK Ltd. The employee was dismissed following concerns about a pattern of sickness absence around holidays and days off, including evidence that she had announced an intention to call in sick after a holiday request was refused. Although she was genuinely ill on that particular occasion, the employment tribunal upheld her dismissal as fair.
Deliberate dishonesty can justify dismissal. In Metroline West Ltd v Ajaj, the Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the dismissal of a bus driver who had deliberately exaggerated the effects of an injury. The key issue was his dishonesty, rather than whether he was genuinely incapable of working.
The message? Employers can take action where there is evidence of misconduct, but they need reasonable grounds for their conclusions and a fair investigation.
What can employers do?
A good starting point is a clear absence management policy which deals specifically with short-term absence. This could expressly identify patterns that may prompt further enquiries, including repeated absences adjoining weekends or bank holidays, or sickness immediately following a refused holiday request.
That doesn’t mean automatically treating such absences as misconduct. It means giving managers a framework for asking appropriate questions and considering the explanation.
Return-to-work meetings are particularly useful. Conducted consistently, they provide an opportunity to establish the reasons for absence, identify underlying health issues and address emerging patterns.
Where there is evidence suggesting dishonesty, a disciplinary investigation may be appropriate. But employers should distinguish misconduct from genuine ill health, including disability-related absence.
Prevention rather than punishment
There is also a case for thinking creatively about leave arrangements.
Some employers offer additional ‘duvet days’: a small allowance of short-notice leave which employees can take without providing a detailed explanation. Others might permit holiday swaps, flexible hours or unpaid leave around major events. These arrangements need clear rules about notice, availability and operational cover. But giving employees legitimate options may be more effective than forcing a choice between attending work and claiming sickness.
Fairness matters too. If a major sporting event or game launch appeals disproportionately to one section of the workforce, employers should avoid assumptions based on age or sex. Leave decisions should follow objective, consistently applied criteria.
The goal for HR should be to do the groundwork to establish clear expectations, investigate concerns fairly and plan ahead for predictable pressure points. To assist with this, members of the HR Inner Circle can access a template Short-term Absence Policy, together with a raft of other supporting resources in the Vault.