Most employers would be concerned to discover that an employee had a second full-time job. Discovering that they had four others is in another league entirely. That was the position in the extraordinary case of civil servant Kashim Chowdhury, who has just been convicted of nine counts of fraud after secretly holding multiple full-time jobs across government departments and public bodies. At one point, he was contracted to work 183 hours a week – more hours than there are in a week!
While Chowdhury’s case is an extreme example of dishonesty, it raises a more everyday question for HR: what are the rules when employees take on additional work?
Can employees have a second job?
There is no general legal prohibition on employees having more than one job. If the employment contract says nothing about secondary employment, employees are generally free to take on additional work.
However, that freedom is not unlimited. Employees owe implied duties to their employer, including a duty of fidelity. Working for a competitor, misusing confidential information or allowing another job to interfere with contractual responsibilities could breach those duties.
The distinction is important. An employee who works in a pub at weekends is in a very different position from someone secretly working for another employer during their contracted working hours. Nor does an employee necessarily have to disclose a second job. Unless there is a contractual requirement to do so, or disclosure is required because of a conflict with their existing duties, there is no general obligation to volunteer that information.
What if the contract prohibits other employment?
Employers can include contractual restrictions on secondary employment, although a requirement to obtain prior consent will often be more appropriate than an outright ban.
There is, however, an important statutory exception. Exclusivity clauses are unenforceable in zero-hours contracts and contracts where a worker’s average weekly income is at or below the statutory lower earnings limit (currently £129 per week). These workers are also protected against dismissal or detrimental treatment for breaching such clauses.
For other employees, employers should consider requests for additional employment reasonably, taking account of genuine business concerns rather than simply objecting in principle.
When does a second job become a problem?
Even where additional employment is permitted, difficulties can arise.
The Working Time Regulations 1998 generally limit working time to an average of 48 hours per week, calculated over a 17-week reference period, unless the worker has opted out. Workers are also generally entitled to 11 consecutive hours’ rest in each 24-hour period and 24 hours’ uninterrupted rest each week (or 48 hours per fortnight), subject to exceptions. Working hours across multiple jobs count towards the 48-hour limit, so employers who know about additional employment should consider the implications for compliance, rest and fatigue.
Remote working adds another dimension. An employee might be meeting their targets, but does that mean they can undertake another employer’s work during the same hours? Much will depend on their contractual obligations and the flexibility of their working arrangements. A clause requiring employees to devote their working time and attention to their employer’s business can help establish clear expectations.
Deliberate dishonesty, falsified timesheets or serious neglect of duties could justify disciplinary action, potentially including dismissal. But simply discovering that someone has another job does not automatically make dismissal fair.
What should HR do?
The Chowdhury case is a useful prompt to review existing arrangements:
- Check contracts: Are employees required to disclose additional employment or obtain consent? Is there an obligation to devote their working time and attention to their job?
- Review policies: Explain when secondary employment may be restricted, including conflicts of interest and competing commitments.
- Consider working time: Establish whether additional work creates risks concerning the 48-hour limit, rest periods or fatigue.
- Investigate concerns: Establish whether there has actually been a breach of contract or misconduct before taking action.
For many employees, additional work is a perfectly legitimate way to supplement their income. The challenge for HR is distinguishing that from arrangements which undermine the employment relationship or breach legal safeguards on working time.